Advice To Young Pitchers: Love Being The Underdog

Madi Osias, former pitcher for the Ole Miss Rebels joins the FloSoftball writing team after the best season in school history. She helped lead the Rebels to their first NCAA tournament appearance. When no one thought they could, they did. This is the mindset of the underdog.


My whole life, people have underestimated me. The Pac-12 turned me down before I even played a high school game. The SEC didn't even bother watching me play. The Big Ten and Big 12 both said thanks but no thanks. In my junior year I committed to the University of Memphis, which at the time was part of Conference USA.

To make a long story short, after a couple of coaching changes I finally landed at the University of Mississippi in the SEC. How could a kid like me, who coaches knowingly passed up in the recruiting process, beat the players they believed were better than me when we were only 13?

Before I even stepped onto the field at Ole Miss in 2013, my mind was filled with self-doubt. "I was never meant to be in the SEC. I'm not good enough to be here. I'm only here because my coach got the job here."

But how could I possibly compete with All-Americans in the SEC? I convinced myself that I had no place on the field with the same girls I faced in travel ball and high school less than a year before. Not only did I create an idea in my head that I wasn't good enough, but I was also scared. I feared being put out on the field against Madison Shipman, Haylie McCleney, and Kelsey Stewart.

For the first three years of my college career, I settled between being average or simply content with not playing at all. It wasn't until my senior year that I realized how good I could be with the right mental approach.

Imagine my pitching mindset as an old dusty box filled with illogical, self-critical thoughts about past pitching performances. Coach Taryne Mowatt came in, picked up the box, and dumped all of its contents in the trash. She then took the box back inside, gave it a fresh coat of paint, and filled it with smart, confident thoughts. Sounds easy right? Always easier said than done.

Confidence is hard to build and easy to break. Let's face it: A majority of pitchers are underdogs. Unless you are pitching for a top 10 team, you are the underdog.

Pitching as the underdog means you are competing against a team that you are not expected to beat. It doesn't mean is that you are not good enough to win, it just means that you are not the favorite to win in the matchup.

While I was at Ole Miss, no one expected us to win. In fact, in my senior year the preseason coaches poll for SEC standings had us ranked 12th out of 13 teams going into the 2016 season. We had nothing to lose and only room for improvement, not a bad place to be if you ask me.

So then what's your game plan? How are you going to defeat Goliath?


  1. PREPARE. Before even stepping onto the field, you should prepare to be successful and use every available resource to your advantage: watch film, scout lineups, pick up on hitting tendencies, and create a game plan. What is a hitter's weakness; what is their strength? How were previous pitchers successful against them? Be confident in your plan and mentally picture getting every single hitter out.
  2. POSITIVITY. Pitching is a mental game within the game of softball. If you go into a game with a losing mentality, you've already set yourself up for failure. Who cares about rankings, batting averages, or the name on the back of a jersey? Good batters get themselves out seven out of 10 times -- the odds are in your favor! Positive self-talk during the game is HUGE. So what if you're not expected to win? Take it as an opportunity to PROVE them wrong. You can do this. You are good enough. You have NOTHING to lose.
  3. TEAMMATE. Be a good teammate. Be more excited for their successes than you own, because if they succeed, you succeed too. Recognize that pitching is not a one person job. Appreciate your catchers, they are the whole reason you look good and are usually the only people who can cover up your mistakes. Appreciate and trust your infield, they have your back. Appreciate your outfield, they are going to keep you in the game, so let them do their job. Understand that pitching is a huge responsibility, but you need a team behind you and a catcher in front of you to defeat Goliath.

Pitching as an underdog is an opportunity for greatness, dressed up as a losing program beating a nationally ranked team on senior night for the first in a decade. Being picked to finish near the bottom of the SEC was our motivation to prove everyone wrong.

Instead of thinking we were never going to beat those teams, we thought "Time to get to work and prove them wrong." And we did. We finished 24th in the nation and eighth in the SEC, beating numerous ranked teams and making it to our first-ever NCAA Regional before losing to the eventual national champion, Oklahoma.

The doubt should fuel your fire. But above all else, have fun. Softball is a game that is meant to be played with passion. So what do you have to lose?

Follow Madi Osias on Twitter & Instagram



Get More From FloSoftball!

Sign up for the FloSoftball newsletter for instant access to: Breaking News, Live Streams, Rankings, Technique Videos and more!

Northwestern Southpaw Danielle Williams Does It All

College Softball Is Here

A four-time FloSoftball High School All-American during her years at Amador Valley High School, Northwestern first-year Danielle Williams made the move to Evanston from Pleasanton, California as the Prep2Prep Sports 2018 North Coast Section Player of the Year and first-team All-North Coast Section.

Rising Star: Aspen Wesley, Future Mississippi State Ace

Aspen Wesley once had visions of playing college basketball. But when the No. 1 Neshoba Central (Mississippi) High Rockets pitcher got her first taste of pitching in the circle at age eight, softball became her new passion.

NPF 2019 Draft Selections Announced

The Chicago Bandits select Florida pitcher Kelly Barnhill as the No. 1 overall pick in the 2019 NPF draft. 

2019 NPF College Draft: How To Watch

It's that time of the year! Some of the best seniors in the nation are taking the next step to become professional athletes. National Pro Fastpitch will be holding its college draft at ACME Feed & Seed in Nashville. Who will be the No. 1 pick this year?

Jessie Harper, Dejah Mulipola, Alyssa Palomino Blast Arizona Record Books

The junior class for the Arizona Wildcats is on a mission to be one of the greatest collection of players not just in program history, but in the nation. Leading the way are a trio — Jessie Harper, Dejah Mulipola, and Alyssa Palomino-Cardoza — who have combined for 50 home runs this season, the most for any three players from one team.

2019 NPF Mock Draft

Historically, pitchers have been the top picks in the NPF draft but we predict this year will be different. Cowles Cup champs USSSA Pride and runner-up Chicago Bandits are stacked with elite pitchers and are in need of position players to strengthen their lineups and defense.

Rising Star: 2020 McNeese State-commit Aaliyah "Papi" Ortiz

Aaliyah Ortiz is better known as “Papi” or “Big Papi,” by her teammates and coaches. The nickname fits, not just because she shares the same last name as the Boston Red Sox star, but because of how her offensive impact on the softball field resembles that of David “Big Papi” Ortiz. 

Through Adversity, Tara Trainer Learns the True Meaning of Success

EXCLUSIVE: On The Field With Indiana

Unlock this video, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

It’s easier to have fun when things are going well. Indiana Hoosiers right-hander Tara Trainer was having her share of good times as a freshman in 2016.

How The NW Bullets Emerged As The Northwest's Premier Club

In 2005, Dennis Muir, Tony Campos, and Warren Hall started the Northwest Bullets. This team of coaches wanted to provide a program for players from the Northwest that would allow them to train and play on the national stage. Campos added, “The purpose of the team was to bring together the best athletes in the northwest, to develop their skills and prepare them to play on a national stage and be recruited by top programs.”

NPF College Draft Returns To Nashville & Acme For Third Year

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (March 5, 2019)– National Pro Fastpitch will hold its annual NPF College Draft for the third consecutive year at the ACME Feed and Seed, located on 1st and Broadway in downtown Nashville, Tennessee. The event will take place on Monday, April 15th at 7:00 pm CT.